Individual
A self-facilitated program to boost your mental fitness for personal and professional growth
Mental Fitness
How Earned Trust Builds Stronger, Safer, and Higher-Performing Teams
The Role of Trust in Team Performance and Well-Being
High-performing teams rely on more than just talent and hard work. What makes them strong is how they work together. They create a team culture based on shared purpose and respect. At the heart of this culture are the 4 Pillars of High-Performing Teams: Triple Purpose, Earned Trust, Healthy Conflict, and Mutual Accountability.
These four elements are deeply connected. Without trust, the rest begins to weaken. When you and your team members feel safe to speak honestly and be open, you work together better, give useful feedback, and learn faster.
Trust helps your team perform well while also feeling secure. It lets you do great work without losing honesty, connection, or psychological safety.
What Makes Trust Earned
Trust isn’t automatically granted based on a job title or role. It grows through consistent, everyday behaviors. These behaviors include being honest about mistakes, showing up reliably, listening with curiosity, and offering help without judgment.
When you feel that your teammates are being real with you, you begin to relax the need for perfection. It becomes easier to speak openly and admit when something didn’t go well. In addition, team members feel more comfortable sharing a concern before it grows into a larger problem.
This trust is not just about believing others mean well. It grows from real experiences, like seeing how people act in tough situations. And it grows when your words and actions match.
Vulnerability plays a central role in this process. When you are willing to be honest about a struggle or uncertainty, it invites others to do the same. Over time, this creates a culture where authenticity becomes the norm rather than the exception.
Why Earned Trust Drives Team Performance
Trust is more than a positive feeling. It’s a practical driver of performance. When trust is strong, giving and receiving feedback feels easier. You are also more willing to speak up about problems.
In a high-trust environment, you tend to take greater ownership of your work. You’re more likely to admit when something goes wrong. You’re also better equipped to offer solutions, and stay committed to shared goals when pressure rises.
On the other hand, when trust is low, those same actions become risky. You may hesitate to share concerns or own mistakes, which slows down problem-solving and limits innovation. Over time, your performance suffers. This is not due to a lack of ability, but because the environment makes it harder to fully engage.
The Role of Mental Fitness in Building Trust
Even when everyone means well, trust can break down when stress, frustration, or fear take over. These feelings come from Saboteurs, which are negative thoughts that change how you see yourself, others, and challenges.
Saboteurs such as the Judge, Avoider, or Controller can make it hard to be open, trust others, or take responsibility without feeling defensive. If even one person has this mindset, it can affect the whole team. Communication becomes harder, teamwork feels risky, and trust gets weaker.
That is why building mental fitness as a team is so important. It helps everyone handle pressure better, share feedback openly, and face tough situations with calm and care. When mental fitness is part of your team’s culture, trust grows stronger, and the team can solve problems together more easily.
How to Build More Trust Across the Team
Developing earned trust doesn’t require a dramatic culture shift. It often begins with small actions and a mindset of openness.
As a leader, a good way to build trust is to show openness. Sharing a recent learning moment or acknowledging a mistake can signal that it’s safe for others to do the same. This kind of leadership builds confidence and connection, even in high-stakes situations.
As a team member, you can also help strengthen trust by showing a genuine interest in others as people, not just colleagues. Take a few minutes to check in. Seek to express appreciation or ask thoughtful questions. This can help create a more human connection, and that connection makes collaboration more resilient.
When problems happen, how you respond matters. If you stop to think and learn instead of blaming, your team will recover and become stronger. This mindset not only protects trust but also reinforces it.
Want to Gauge Where Your Team Stands?
The PQ-Powered Teamwork Assessment offers a quick way to explore your team’s strengths and opportunities across the 4 Pillars of High-Performing Teams, including Earned Trust. It’s a helpful entry point for conversations that can build deeper connections and long-term momentum.
When you and your team members trust one another, you’re more likely to speak with honesty. You’re also more empowered to take responsibility for outcomes and approach challenges as a shared effort. That foundation makes it easier to do great work and enjoy working together.
Get a Free Team Performance Report
Get Your Free Report
Case Study: Unlocking Potential at Young Guns
Read the Case Study
